We finally got rid of Snicker. I say "got rid of" and "we," but neither is accurate. Here's what happened, really.
We got her from Animal Defense League 4 months ago - an adult dog who'd just had puppies. She was small, sweet, cute, short-haired, good-natured about Matt wrestling and loving on her. Sort of housetrained; she'd wait and go outside if we kept on top of it. A win, when I thought about what we could have been going through with a puppy.
There was a downside, one that I tried to look past. Apparently abused by a tall, white male (judging by the few times I heard her growl at people), she was incredibly anxious about being left alone. The first night, I crated her in the laundry room, but she almost chewed her way out, and had knocked the crate across the room, destroyed a rug. We let her sleep on Matt's bed. I was home writing during the day, so I only left her for brief periods, during which she'd maybe pee in the office or strew the trash all around and eat stuff. I can get past this, I told myself.
She bonded to me, since I was home all day, and she hated to be left alone. She was up my butt all day long. I still had trouble getting her to accept me as the alpha, though. She walked me, pulling me and jerking me, stepping in front of me, obstinately stopping and pulling back. After weeks of struggling with her, reading books, watching videos, talking to everyone I knew with dogs, I finally got tough enough with her that she'd show belly at any sign of displeasure from me, but remained disobedient whenever she thought she could get away with it. We worked on "Sit" for four months, and she still wouldn't do it reliably.
And the housetraining was driving me nuts. Since I was training for the Danskin triathlon, I took Snicker on my long morning walks. She got used to peeing and pooping a mile from the house. Unfortunately, she'd no longer go in the yard, so if we didn't take her on the long jaunt at the right time, she'd pee in the house. Increasingly a problem. We couldn't leave her in the yard, because she could get out - under, over, through the fence, and if I chained her, she'd destroy stuff or wind her chain around things and trap herself away from her water bowl. I went back to crate training, but she could outlast me all day rather than pee in the backyard. I was spending all day trying to train the damned dog, not writing, not working, fuming.
At the same time, I'm in therapy to learn to express my anger. And dear little Snicker was a very handy anger target. The millionth time I walked her in the back yard, praying for her to pee, I'd lose it and yell at her, knowing it was just going to make things worse. When I found a big pee puddle in the office where I'd carefully blotted, cleaned and deodorized yesterday, I yelled at her again, swatted her flank, directly against the advice of every dog training treatise.
It got so that everything she did irritated me. The more she cowered, the more I hated her. I fantasized about killing her, dumping her in the country. At one point, I opened the front door and pushed her out on the porch. She refused to go. Each time, I'd vow to keep my temper, stop traumatizing her and making it worse. The problems were all my fault, for losing my temper, being impatient.
I contacted some trainers, most of whom prefaced their comments with, "That's probably why she was at Animal Defense in the first place." I dreamed of sending her to boot camp and having her come back home, all housebroken and trained. The trainers weren't willing to take her, though, since she wasn't reliably housetrained.
I have a problem setting boundaries in my life, my therapist tells me. She and Greg asked repeatedly if I wanted to get rid of the dog, since I was griping about her all the time. I didn't; I felt she was a good fit in many respects, I'd made a commitment to including her in our family. Matt loved her. I'd feel like I'd failed with her, not done the training right, not made enough effort. I was always willing to do a bit more to work things out.
When school let out, Greg started doing a lot of the Snicker stuff. It was affirming to hear that, indeed, taking care of Snicker was a ton of work. Too much work.
Greg and I took Matt to his swim lesson at 5:45. Snicker was at home, still crated, because she hadn't peed on any of the dozen backyard walks. Greg asked me to decide; was I ready to get rid of her? I didn't have to dedicate my life to this dog, we could turn her in. I finally agreed. He went back to move her to the chain outside, since we were both afraid she'd ruin something in the house. I felt guilty about it, but relieved. I called Julie to vent.
When we returned home an hour later, there was Snicker out front, bristling and growling at some neighbor's leashed dog. Her chain was wrapped around the tree, the collar left dangling off the ground where she would have hung herself if she hadn't been able to slip it over her head.
I'm sure it was traumatic for her. I tried to feel something for her besides disgust. I called the Animal Defense League first thing in the morning, but they were closed until noon, have a month-to-month waiting list going. The Humane Society accepts animals on a space-available basis on MWF, with appointment, but you have to call on those mornings. No. I was finally OUT of Snicker coping, completely out. I walked her a couple more times before Greg took her to the pound for me.
Matt is sad about losing her, but his main observation was, "People who knew we had her will ask about her." And I said, yep, they will. We'll just tell them the truth." I told him I was sorry, but I'd tried as much as I was willing to try. And he's seen that I have.
I hear the jingle of her tags, the furtive biting at the hot spot on her flank I used to tend with Benadryl. I still carefully close the door to the pantry, even though I don't need to anymore. Ghost of a dog.
My parents lied to me about the demise of my first and second dogs, and I was greatly disillusioned when I found out. I minded that more than losing the dogs. So I told Matt the truth about her final fate - she'll probably be put to death, though there's a slight chance someone will adopt her. I hope so. She's sweet, cute, short-haired. Almost housetrained.